Hello dear
Welcome To Coffaros' Pizza
Coffaros' Pizza, nestled at 116 S Broad St in Grove City, PA, is a beloved local gem renowned for its outstanding pizza and warm service. With glowing reviews that highlight the chewy, flavorful crust and fresh, buttery cheese, fans rave about the quality and taste that sets it apart from the ordinary. Owner Sal's commitment to excellence resonates in every slice, complemented by a well-priced menu that doesn’t compromise on flavor. From the spicy pepperoni to the highly recommended "Awesome Sauce," each dish reflects care and passion. For pizza lovers seeking a delightful experience, Coffaros' Pizza is truly a must-try spot.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Coffaros' Pizza
Welcome to Coffaros' Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Grove City, Pennsylvania. This unassuming eatery at 116 S Broad St has quickly become a local favorite, recognized for its dedication to quality and affordable pricing.
When you step inside Coffaros' Pizza, you're greeted not only by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizza but also by a warm and friendly atmosphere. As one customer, Bantam, aptly stated, the service here is commendable, with staff members like Cole, Steve, and Cody ensuring that every guest feels welcomed. Their commitment to customer service is matched only by their passion for crafting outstanding pizzas.
Now, let’s talk about the pizza itself. Patrons rave about the exceptional quality; Jamie Mattus highlights the zero flop on the crust—a sign of expert preparation and baking. The owner, Sal, clearly takes pride in his craft, ensuring that the flavors shine through while keeping the prices reasonable in today’s economy. You'll quickly discover that quality doesn’t have to come with a hefty price tag.
And what about the pizza? Jason Keith describes it as absolutely delicious, with a harmonious blend of textures and flavors. The crust strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crunchy, while the cheese is buttery and fresh. The spiced pepperoni adds that punch of flavor that is simply too good to resist. For those who enjoy a little extra sauce, don’t forget to ask for their signature Awesome Sauce, which elevates the flavor profile even further.
Not just a one-trick pony, Coffaros' Pizza also impresses with a variety of menu items. Customer Richard Johnson was so taken with the Sicilian pizza that he’s now eager to explore other offerings. Meanwhile, Robert Long expresses a fondness for their hoagie specialties, particularly the steak hoagie, proving that excellence extends beyond just pizza.
In summary, Coffaros' Pizza is a testament to what a small, community-focused restaurant can achieve. With its stellar service, exceptional pizza, and dedication to quality without financial strain, it’s no wonder that Coffaros' has captured the hearts (and appetites) of many. Whether you dine in or take out, one visit to this local treasure will undoubtedly leave you craving more.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Cole, Steve and Cody were great servers! Great pizza too! Couldn’t ask for better pizza in America. ”
“ Great pizza zero flop!! Sal The owner is a great guy he takes pride in what he does and you can taste it!!! Also with everything costing a fortune right now e keeps his pieces down while maintaining Quality ”
“ Absolutely delicious! I was in the area for a night and Coffaros' Pizza was highly recommended. This is one of THE best pizzas I've had! The crust is chewy, crunchy, and flavorful. The cheese is buttery, silky, and obviously very fresh. The pepperoni is spicy (not hot), and very meaty. It is not your typical store bought sausage. The ONLY thing that I can suggest is to request some extra sauce on the pie, or on the side. (They have what is meant by "Awesome Sauce" ) ”
“ First visit and just ordered a pizza to sample their product. Got a Sicilian, and it was great. I'm definitely going back to try other items on the menu. ”
“ We've done plenty of take out. My daughters love the pizza and I love the hoagie bread. I think my favorite so far is the steak hoagie. Priced well and great food! ”
“ I've been traveling all day and I was really craving some good pizza. The front desk lady at my hotel suggested this place. If you are in the area, order from here! This is probably the best pizza I've ever had. Or at least top 2! The crust was crispy on the outside, warm and chewy on the inside. Perfect tasting sauce, a well balance of sweet to savory. And the cheese was very fresh and delicious. I'll be traveling back and forth to Westpoint the next few years and I will 100% make it a point to stop in and get this pizza. I'm posting a picture, but the pizza is a little lopsided from me tipping it over. Not from the pizza place. ”
“ Best pizza in Grove city, IMO. Not too heavy, cooked to perfection, decent undercarriage. Pepperoni and banana pepper is my go to, and this place nails it. ”
“ They have the best pizza in Grove City!!! Wonderful, hard working staff! This is me and my boyfriend’s favorite pizza place! It is heavenly goodnesssss, try the cheesy bread! ”